Easy Maple Sugar Shortbread

Easy Maple Sugar Shortbread I don’t really consider myself much of a food snob for as much as I think, talk, and write about food. I’m not above a DiGiorno’s frozen pizza or a (family-sized) bag of Doritos now and then. But there are two items I’m totally and obnoxiously particular about: coffee and maple syrup.

The coffee one’s a no brainer. Bad coffee just isn’t worth drinking. Don’t get me wrong…I’m not going out and spending $4 a cup at the local cafe…but I make my own coffee, grind up my own relatively fresh beans, and (politely and secretly) turn my nose up at coffee that’s been around too long.

When we were first married, Eric didn’t even really drink coffee, and he would insist that a gas station coffee was as good as any when we were on a road trip. I would look at him, lovingly and pitying-ly, and tell him he was wrong, insisting he make an extra stop during our pit stop to get some real coffee.

Easy Maple Sugar Shortbread And then there’s maple syrup. For years, I would read recipes that called for “pure maple syrup” and would totally ignore it, loyally turning to Aunt Jemima and her familiar ways. And even though I grew up in Wisconsin which produces a whole lot of maple syrup, and even though I went on a field trip in third grade to see how maple syrup was produced, all I really remember about the experience was the maple cookie we got before getting back on the bus.

It wasn’t until just recently that I bought pure maple syrup…I don’t even remember why – maybe to put in Owen’s plain yogurt in lieu of honey? – and it was sort of a revelation.

Sorry, Auntie J., you hold no candle to the pure stuff.

Let me just say this: if you invite me to your house and you feed me pancakes with the cheapest syrup you can buy, I will eat them…with great relish and gusto.

Easy Maple Sugar Shortbread But I’m telling you…pure maple syrup is worth the extra dollars.
So when I saw this maple sugar shortbread recipe in The Northern Heartland Kitchen cookbook, I knew it had to be mine. I also knew that it was May and that you who are reading this might be thinking….ummm, were you going to cook anything with spinach or asparagus or strawberries this spring?  And my answer is a resounding Yes. But it just finished snowing and nothing but grass is really growing ’round these parts yet…except for maple syrup.

This is prime syrup making time for trees…and these warm days and cold nights we’ve been having are just what those trees want to make their syrup.

I bet you have everything you need to make this shortbread in your house right now. Ready? Butter, maple or light brown sugar, vanilla extract, salt, flour, and cornstarch? Was I right? 5 inredients, and out of them comes the most delightfully crispy, sugary sweet, maple-laden shortbread cookie that longs to be had with an afternoon cup of good coffee. They are equally enjoyable at breakfast.

Maple sugar is made by boiling down sap until almost all the water has evaporated and all that remains is crystalized. That crystalized portion becomes maple sugar. It is twice as sweet as regular granulated sugar and has a strong maple flavor to it. I did not have maple sugar or light brown sugar on hand, so when I searched how to “make” light brown sugar and saw that you just add molasses to white sugar, I thought, what’s to stop me from just adding maple syrup instead of molasses?

Easy Maple Sugar Shortbread And so I did, and I came out with a pretty maple-y sugar. I’m guessing that real maple sugar, when used in this shortbread, will give you a more pronounced maple flavor, but this was a pretty great substitute.

Go ahead. Pay for some pure maple syrup with its equal weight in gold, and make this shortbread and get your food snobbery on right.

Easy Maple Sugar Shortbread

Easy Maple Sugar Shortbread

(recipe slightly adapted from The Northern Heartland Kitchen )

(yields 8 wedge-shaped pieces in a 9-inch pie pan)

This delightfully crispy shortbread is maple-y sweet and perfect with a cup of tea or coffee. With only five ingredients, it comes together quickly. See note in the ingredients about substituting for maple sugar.


1/2 c. cold unsalted butter, cut into chunks

1/4 c. maple sugar or light brown sugar, plus about 1 tbsp. for topping*

1 tsp. vanilla extract

pinch of salt

3/4 c. all-purpose flour

2 tbsp. cornstarch


*Using Smitten Kitchen's advice for how to make light brown sugar, I made my own version of maple sugar for this recipe instead by mixing 1/4 c. + 1 tbsp. granulated sugar with a scant 1 tsp. of PURE maple syrup (more exactly 1/4 + 1/8 tsp. of maple syrup)


Preheat oven to 350*. Place a metal pie pan or fluted metal tart pan in the freezer to chill while making dough. In a food processor, blend together the butter, all but 1 tbsp. of the maple sugar, vanilla and salt until it is light, about 20 seconds. Sprinkle in the flour and cornstarch, and pulse 4 to 8 times until the dough begins to clump together. (No food processor? Use a pastry cutter and some serious forearm strength or quick fingers!).

Turn the dough into your chilled pan and quickly press it out evenly. The key is to keep the dough cold, so work quickly. If the dough is sticking to your fingers, lay a layer of plastic wrap over the dough and press down on that. Sprinkle the dough with remaining maple sugar and return to the freezer to chill for another 5 minutes.

Remove from the freezer, and use a fork to prick the dough all over. Bake the shortbread until its edges begin to brown and the center is firm, 25-30 minutes. Watch it closely near the end; it can start to burn pretty quickly. Cool the shortbread on a wire rack for a few minutes. While it is still warm, cut into wedges. Let the shortbread cool completely before removing it from the pan.

Keeps well under plastic wrap on the counter for about 3 days.

keep cold! if you're having trouble - use plastic wrap to press into pan; prick after freezing for 5 mins.


You might also like:

7 thoughts on “Easy Maple Sugar Shortbread

  1. The last time I had imitation maple syrup was in one of those tiny tear-open packets at a hotel continental breakfast. I don’t think corn syrup has a smell – but in my brain, that’s what it smells like!

    Last year I made a homemade version of maple sugar. Boiled (using a candy thermometer!) the maple syrup with some butter and then allowed it to cool before crumbling. The texture is the exact same as maple sugar. It would be perfect in this!!

  2. I am completely with you on the coffee thing. I’ve only been drinking coffee for like a year, but I just can’t handle the cheap stuff. But I will admit that I prefer the cheap, non-pure maple syrup because it’s what I grew up with :)

  3. I have to say that I became a converted PURE MAPLE SYRUP Snob when I tried some for the first time! When I moved to Washington State 8 years ago my whole world changed on what foods were good for you, what were bad, and pretty much my whole life i have been eating horrible, HIGH FRUCTOSE laden, FAKE junk, and the REAL thing was in the same isle, but I guess invisible to me. I too had a thing for the Aunt J, I even have a Vintage Ceramic one in my Kitchen as my Grandma did, but I have never looked back once I found the REAL DEAL!! Who can beat the taste, let alone it has minerals in it, AND it is not Genetically Modified, as 90% of Corn is that is used in the making of HFCS, which Aunt J is LOADED with!
    I found a place in Vermont that sells it by the gallon, along with the maple sugar, and a maple butter (spreadable consistency for toast etc) It is a family ran business I found on Etsy, topofthehillmaple.etsy.com
    Great recipe, I seriously cannot wait to indulge with my freshly ground cup of Medium Roast Brazillian Coffee in the morning!!!!

  4. I’m with Melissa on this one, though I have to put a plug in for my own family farm here in Minnesota: http://righteousoaksfarm.wordpress.com/about/real-maple-syrup/. It’s just so much cheaper to buy straight from the farmer or in bulk at your local co-op.

    There are so many reasons to cut out High Fructose Corn Syrup, my main reason is that it blocks the zinc uptake in our bodies. Here’s a great post with some other great reasons to shun the nasty stuff: http://www.kitchenstewardship.com/2013/02/11/back-to-basics-baby-step-monday-mission-no-6-cut-high-fructose-corn-syrup/. And don’t get me started on GMOs. Argh. A political nightmare. Call me a snob, but I just can’t put this stuff in my kids.

    This recipe looks great. Look forward to trying it!

    We’ll be in the cities this weekend. Mat has his last scan, hopefully, for the cancer he had. Maybe we’ll see you on Sunday.

  5. Recommendation for someone who has root vegetables on her banner….get the Shelburne Farms recipe for maple braised root veggies. Maple and root veg….what more shall I offer!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Current ye@r *